Skip to content
An official website of the OECD. Find out more
Created by the Public Governance Directorate

This website was created by the OECD Observatory of Public Sector Innovation (OPSI), part of the OECD Public Governance Directorate (GOV).

How to validate authenticity

Validation that this is an official OECD website can be found on the Innovative Government page of the corporate OECD website.

Citibeats – Ethical AI for Social Understanding

Sustainability Screenshot with Highlights of statistics on sustainability

We live in an infodemic context. A lot of data doesn't mean good data. This brings to question the information sources and the data itself. Decision-makers don’t understand citizens’ needs and act based on uninformed decisions, and citizens feel neglected. This generates a systemic lack of trust. Citibeats' ethical AI makes helps governments interpret the huge quantity of data exchanged every day by citizens in real time, understand their needs, and make faster and better-informed decisions.

Innovation Summary

Innovation Overview

Citibeats is a B2B SaaS ethical AI platform that searches and analyzes large amounts of text provided by citizens - we structure this data (using NPL and ML) and identify social trends, leading indicators, and insights for governments, and organizations. Citibeats offers a much more complex analysis and interpretation of data than brand watching. Instead of being purely focused on single keywords, our research method is culturally focused, language-agnostic, easily adaptable, and monitors complex narratives evolving over time around a specific topic and that involves other related subtopics and multiple opinions expressed by users. Given the velocity of events that affect people on a local and global scale, governments cannot afford to lose time detecting social risks and reacting consequently. Our platform gives them a qualitative and temporal edge - that traditional survey methods or the media cannot compete with - to improve citizens’ living conditions. Our Sustainability and the Social Risks Monitors - featuring historical and real-time data points in more than 100 countries and in more than 10 languages updated daily - help organizations around the globe rapidly and easily understand citizens’ questions, needs, and concerns around topics like climate change, sustainability, migration, citizen security, employment, and more.

During the last four years, Citibeats has informed over $1 billion in social risk mitigation decisions, both in the public and private sectors, being able to detect early warning signs in social fast-changing environments. CivicLytics (the citizens’ Observatory for Latin America and the Caribbean created in collaboration with IDB) and the EARS project (the World Health Organization’s social listening platform to show real-time information about how people are talking about COVID-19 online to better manage the evolution of the infodemic and the pandemic) are just two of the company’s most impactful use cases. Citibeats is proud to collaborate with global entities like IDB and WHO to address social issues and epochal changes as the biggest pandemic of our lives. Both projects are great examples of how Citibeats’ technology can help governments and organizations understand citizens’ perceptions and concerns to improve their public policies and projects by including people’s needs in their decision-making process.

In LATAM, the IDB Group uses Citibeats as its internal platform to inform all member countries, sharing aggregate data and providing generalized visibility of the challenges facing the region. In addition, with the public website CivicLytics, data is accessible to all citizens so that they can refer to it and contribute their voice. In the first 2 months of the project, more than 100 million tweets were analyzed, detecting alerts such as hunger risks in Venezuela and Colombia, hygiene risks due to lack of running water in major cities in Central American. Other projects focus on the economic recovery of countries such as Panama and the growth of the Amazon Basin, a project focused initially on 7 countries (Bolivia, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Guyana, Peru and Suriname), the project took into account different topics (health, security, biodiversity, education, environment, bioeconomy and more). From November 2020 to July 2021, the project included the analysis of more than 288,603 opinions expressed by citizens on digital documents (blogs, forum comments, tweets, news, websites, etc.) about the Amazon region.

Apart from multilateral organizations, we had the opportunity to work with regional and national governments and city councils (Dublin, Navarra, Japan, and more), and private companies (namely, Telefónica and NTT Data, two of the largest telcos in the world). We have recently launched a new business model based on a monthly subscription licence model. In particular, we have created the Sustainability and the Social Risks Monitors to help organizations around the globe rapidly and easily understand citizens’ questions, needs, and concerns around topics like climate change, biodiversity, sustainable cities, migration, citizen security, employment and entrepreneurship, and more.

Innovation Description

What Makes Your Project Innovative?

Contrary to marketing brand watching, Citibeats offers a much more complex analysis and interpretation of data. Instead of being purely focused on single keywords, our research method is culturally focused, language-agnostic, easily adaptable, and monitors complex narratives evolving over time around a specific topic and that involves other related subtopics and multiple opinions expressed by users.

Citibeats’ AI analyzes large amounts of unstructured text data and other types of files where text can be extracted to identify in real time, social trends, people’s opinions, and concerns. All this information - collected and centralized in the dashboard of our platform - represents precious actionable insights for governments, multilateral organizations, and private companies to act upon and improve citizen's lives. Reacting to leading indicators helps our clients act faster, with a social and economic positive impact.

What is the current status of your innovation?

During these last 4 years, we’ve successfully been working with different organizations, such as WHO, IDB, UNESCO, World Bank, and UNDP; governments such as the municipality of Dublin, Ireland, and Navarra, Spain; and also private companies, like Telefonica and NTT Data. Citibeats has informed over $1 billion in social risk mitigation decisions, both in the public and private sectors, being able to detect early warning signs in social fast-changing environments.

Citibeats’ platform has been designed to guarantee high scalability and access to anyone (and not just expert data scientists); structure multilingual data in minutes to detect social development and sustainability trends faster; collect data —in different languages, dialects, slang, and new, local, or domain-specific vocabulary—from more than 85 countries around the world; significantly reduce bias from people’s opinions and calibrate the results before delivering them to our clients.

Innovation Development

Collaborations & Partnerships

  • Clients: WHO, IDB, UNESCO, World Bank, and UNDP; Governments such as the municipality of Dublin, Ireland, and Navarra, Spain - helped us achieve our revenue goals and become a leader in ethical and responsible AI.
  • Tech partners: Microsoft, Facebook, Twitter, OHVcloud, Nvidia, AWS - helped us in the data collection and cloud computing side of the company
  • Investors (and Clients): IDB Lab, CAF, Telefonica, NTT Data - helped us scale and grow

Users, Stakeholders & Beneficiaries

  • EARS - 84,622,806 opinions collected, 30 countries covered
  • CivicLytics - 39,226,553 opinions collected, 26 countries covered
  • Amazon Basin Project - 327,080 opinions collected, 7 countries covered (As a result, in October 2021, the Green Climate Fund approved financing for the Amazon Project of 279M)
  • We have informed over $1 billion in social risk mitigation decisions, both in the public and private sectors, being able to detect early warning signs in social fast-changing environments.

Innovation Reflections

Results, Outcomes & Impacts

Citibeats' Social Understanding technology has been used by international organizations like WHO, World Bank, IDB Group, UNESCO, and UNDP to interpret citizens' needs and help local, regional, and national governments act timely to satisfy people's demands (up to 90 days before traditional survey methods and the media). Our AI platform has been implemented globally being able to collect real-time data from +70 countries, thanks to its agnostic set-up.

We measured the results of our technology based on the voices collected (over 1 billion) and on the more than $1 billion in social risk mitigation decisions that we informed (both in the private and public sectors). In particular, thanks to our collaboration with IDB, in October 2021, the Green Climate Fund approved financing for the Amazon Project of 279M to foster and support the cultural and economic growth of the region. As a result of this, we were recognized as a 2022 Technology Pioneer by the World Economic Forum.

Challenges and Failures

The primary challenge is represented by funding. We are raising an 8€ Series A round that we schedule to close at the end of Q3 2022 to fund our global expansion to the US and to strengthen our positions in Europe, Asia & LATAM. There is still a lot to be done to educate the industry about an ethical and responsible approach to technology in general and to AI specifically. To that end, we are promoting initiatives (like https://www.citibeats.com/ethical-ai-community) and taking part in events about key topics such as ethics in technology, responsible AI, govtech, gender data, detection of bias in data, and more.

Seeing that the project model was not working, we have recently launched a new business model based on a monthly subscription license model. In particular, we have created the Sustainability, Health, and Social Risks Monitors to help organizations around the globe rapidly and easily understand citizens’ questions, needs, and concerns around those topics.

Conditions for Success

We work primarily with multilateral organizations that, by their nature, are strictly connected to local, regional, and national governments. We think that one of the main conditions for a social understanding platform like ours to succeed globally is to be adopted by big organizations like the EU or the UN. To reach that level, it is necessary to educate policy-makers about the necessity to interpret unbiased data in real time. In this society, time is of the essence. As said, we are also looking for financing to scale, especially in the US market.

Being a company with a social focus might sound idealistic, but experience has confirmed our vision. We have the expertise and the technical know-how to impact citizens’ lives in a positive way, and we plan to affect 2B€ in budgets from decisions made from our solution one year from now. Citibeats is the first piece of a technological and social mosaic that has the responsibility to bring humanity back into the decision-making.

Replication

Citibeats' platform has the advantage of being agnostic and easily adaptable to any kind of research. During the last 4 years, we've been collecting over 1 billion data around topics such as social risk, migration, health, vaccines, sustainability, etc. The change from a project model to a subscription model largely depended on the availability of this huge quantity of data collected, on the "open" nature of the platform, and on the easy applicability of our approach.

Any organization or institution, today, can access our data by purchasing a license and start learning immediately citizens' opinions and needs. There is also the possibility to customize the analysis to reflect the needs of the clients, by creating specific categories. We created a technology that is rapidly deployable just to help decision-makers be rapidly and better informed about any societal change and act consequently and timely.

Lessons Learned

History should help us learn from past mistakes and not repeat them, and even if humanity has never been that good in applying that principle so far, we believe that we might have reached a point in our social evolution where a change is possible and, now more than ever, necessary.

That change will be promoted by people and powered by an ethical use of technology focused on creating the conditions to bring humanity to a more responsible level of evolution. This will help make society more inclusive and representative, promote a sustainable and socially responsible approach to the economy and foster and defend values like diversity, gender equality, and self-determination.

In 4 years, we've seen how fast and profoundly society is changing. We need more companies (tech and non-tech) that stand as a bridge, as a connection between citizens and institutions and organizations. Otherwise, our progress as a society will be only partial and not equally distributed.

Anything Else?

Citibeats has been recognized internationally with prestigious awards such as:

  • The United Nations World Summit Awards;
  • The COGx for the best Artificial Intelligence for public services.
  • The NTT Open Innovation contest (that gave us the opportunity to work and develop a project with NTT Data)
  • We are also one of the first four tech startups to successfully implement the ethical self-assessment for entrepreneurs tool promoted by fAIr LAC and IDB Lab.

Project Pitch

Supporting Videos

Year: 2018
Level of Government: Other

Status:

  • Evaluation - understanding whether the innovative initiative has delivered what was needed
  • Diffusing Lessons - using what was learnt to inform other projects and understanding how the innovation can be applied in other ways

Innovation provided by:

Media:

Date Published:

20 January 2023

Join our community:

It only takes a few minutes to complete the form and share your project.