To help citizens, health professionals and authorities to handle the Covid-19 pandemic, TISK IKT, a set of interconnected digital solutions, was set up by the Norwegian Directorate of Health. Through exchanging health data, it set a national record in cooperation between 9 government agencies and the medical association to innovate new digital solutions at extremely high speed.
Innovation Summary
Innovation Overview
TISK-IKT is a system of digital solutions set up in short time to help citizens, health professionals and authorities to handle the pandemic. The digital solutions included "unique ID to citizen", "booking of test time", "portal for registering rapid test results by health professionals", "test results to citizen via messaging", "test results to citizen in national health portal", "combined entry data into Norway and test results for local pandemic tracking", and "Covid-19 passport".
10 parties (9 government agencies and the medical association) cooperated to set up each solution, their interconnections and the exchange of data to and from various registries – based on what already existed of national infrastructure supplied with new development. TISK IKT is a technical innovation, but also more than that, it is an organisational innovation, bringing together agencies owning pieces of the solution and stimulating cooperation between them. Normally, agencies across sectors, do not cooperate this way. Different priorities, key resources allocated to other tasks and low level of "ownership" to the common challenge make it hard to get an efficient collaboration. With TISK IKT we got a whole new approach, stimulating agencies to cooperate on key issues with managerial support from each agency, which might be its biggest innovation achievement.
Independent project teams with participants from the relevant agencies were assigned each part of the programme under a small program management. The program office ensured overall communication with the teams, encouraging bilateral communication between teams working on related tasks. Each part was developed according to a broad plan, with agile project management, and with detailed architecture only were strictly needed.During the pandemic, speed mattered. Norway is broadly acknowledged for having handled the pandemic fairly well with a low number of deaths and socioeconomic burden. As far as we know, Norway was among the first countries to have its EU-compatible Covid-19 passport ready for use.
It is relevant to note that the cooperation established through organisational innovation in TISK IKT has already been re-used to set up integrated digital solutions for helping Ukrainian refugees.
Innovation Description
What Makes Your Project Innovative?
Innovation in the public sector is about renewing or creating something new that creates value for citizens, businesses and/or society or organizational innovation. TISK IKT has created solutions in all four groups. Partly we have created solutions that are completely new - for example the system for local pandemic tracking with travel and test data, as well as the Covid-19 certificate.
In addition, we have created solutions that are somewhat new variants/additions on a known basis - for example a contact register for municipal doctors based on an existing national Address Registry. Moreover, we have taken familiar solutions to be used used in a new way - for example one health region's laboratory requisition solution which, with a bit of remodeling, became the new Rapid Test Portal. Last, but not least, we have seen organisational innovation bringing several agencies together in joint collaboration patterns.
What is the current status of your innovation?
Parts of TISK IKT is still live and running since there is a need for people travelling abroad to document their Covid-19-status.
- Other parts of the solution have been put to rest, ready to be re-deployed should the pandemic resurface again.
- We are regularly diffusing lessons - using what was learnt to inform other projects and understanding how the innovation can be applied in other ways.
- We are also working on project methodology in order to understand how the organisational innovation can be institutionalised
Innovation Development
Collaborations & Partnerships
- Municipalities – user insight vital to develop most useful solutions
- GPs – user insight based on their contact with patients
- Companies – technical know-how for agile development of solutions
Users, Stakeholders & Beneficiaries
- Citizens – solutions for self-service (time scheduling, test results, Covid-19 passports)
- Health personnel – solutions to report test results to registries and to citizens
- Municipalities – solutions for enhanced pandemic tracking and monitoring
Innovation Reflections
Results, Outcomes & Impacts
Health test results have traditionally been communicated and explained by healthcare personnel. A digital solution on the portal "National online health services in Norway" (Helsenorge) became the main channel for sending and explaining more than 11 million test results to citizens (the entire population in Norway is 5,4 million) which would otherwise require communication in a different way or a different handling of the result. Citizens have booked time for more than 750,000 Covid-19 tests electronically, saving time both for them and healthcare personnel. The proportion of e-consultations with GPs went from approximately 5% before the pandemic to almost 30% during and after the pandemic. More than 46 million Covid-19 certificates have been downloaded. We expect the rise in citizen digital self-service via Helsenorge to stay at a high level.
Challenges and Failures
Two big challenges:
- Take a helicopter perspective frequently enough to expand and reorganize the organisation fast enough to take on an expanding list of required solutions based on new, politically decided restrictions in travel, testing, etc. At one occasion we were pretty close to a situation where too few assigned resources would unnecessarily slow down development.
- Combining data from various registries into one pandemic monitoring system for health professionals in primary health care where more challenging than expected. It has not been fully solved yet and has to be worked on.
Conditions for Success
- Explain the common threat and nurturing a sense of urgency to the entire programme team
- A laser focus on a common purpose and goal
- Management-backed accept for taking risk beyond what is normal for civil servants
- Leadership and guidance pointing out the main direction and at the same time giving way for independent teams to work agile and coming up with good solutions and ideas
- Backing from management in each agency
- Financial resources available or provided on short notice
- A strong, enthusiastic and diverse team, respecting each other's competence and experience; and driving on each other's strengths
- Use of existing registries either holding data or being able to consume more data in a new legal framework
- Use of existing, publicly owned, digital, shared components like registries for authorization of users and log-in-identification of inhabitants
Replication
The involved organisations have looked at how the experiences could help them adjust project management practices in their own agencies. "Short and fat" projects has become a term and a goal, working more efficient in public projects compared to low-intensity, long-lasting projects that tend to consume more resources overall. The way of working in TISK IKT (particularly the pieces making several agencies working well together) has been replicated in creating digital solutions for Ukrainian refugees fleeing into Norway, which is still being further developed.
Lessons Learned
- Set up independent teams working agile
- To give a public project a shorter timeline than normal might help stimulate speed and still meet quality criteria
- Hold up the purpose in order to bring good ideas forward
- Active involvement of and an open and transparent communication with a wide range of user groups, especially the The Norwegian Association of the Blind and Partially Sighted was actively involved in the development of the Covid-19 certificate
- Innovative use of SoMe (ie. Slack) to create a two-wide dialogue with different tech communities
Anything Else?
Health information should and must not go astray. It is absolutely essential for citizens to have confidence in sharing sensitive information. TISK IKT has involved lawyers from the start in each individual work package - and in the entire program - to ensure that privacy and information security were safeguarded and built into the solutions right from the start. We tend to say that we have had Norway's fastest public lawyers.
Supporting Videos
Status:
- Diffusing Lessons - using what was learnt to inform other projects and understanding how the innovation can be applied in other ways
Date Published:
24 November 2023